the epic frustrations of : what we learned and where we're left - best buy projector

Two days before the HBO premiere in the first part of the case against Adnan Saeed, the Maryland appeals court resumed the murder conviction that the Circuit Court judge revoked on 2016. The 4-
Three decisions by the state's Supreme Court have shattered the hopes of Saeed and his fanatic supporters for a new trial that killed 18 people on 1999. year-Old Hai Min Li.
So what exactly should we look at, after more than four years of crushing-
In addition to another epic study of frustration, the popular podcast series puts the case of Saeed on the ear. "I think we're going deeper now because time has helped us, and director Amy Berg told E:" Serial has helped dig a lot of new information, so hopefully we're closer to the truth now! "!
The news of the month before Docu
Series premiere.
Here's the friction.
"I think Adnan may have done it, but the case is full of reasonable doubts," Dan Abrams, ABC News legal analyst, told Nancy Grace in a series of clips in 2018.
At the age of 19, inspired reportsyear-
The old murder between the four. part HBO show.
As series host Sarah koenich pointed out in accepting the pebodi Award --
The first podcast
Her accidental cultural sensation in 2015
Hour audio documentary about an ancient murdershe]did not solve.
"As she said, she did not have an agenda set out to prove Saeed's innocence or guilt.
She just wanted to explain the circumstances of the case, the investigation and the two trials.
Declared invalid at the first trial
End on the 19 thyear-
Old Saeed was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder and 35 years for kidnapping.
Serial trigger static-raging did-he-do-
It triggered a heated debate.
The popularity of crime podcasts has not declined. Koenig—
Who wrote about the Baltimore Sun 2000 trial-
Regarding whether Saeed had killed Lee, she did not say anything when she disappeared on January.
1999, his predecessor. girlfriend.
But what she elaborated in serial killer did leave a serious loophole in the process that led to his conviction, it was sufficient for the judge to agree on 2016 that Saeed was not adequately defended at the trial.
The key reason for the Baltimore Circuit Court Judge Martin Welchcited quote is: it is speculated that at the critical time of the day when Lee disappeared, the mobile tower data locked the location of Saeed without using the information she had (
Fax Cover sent with record)
Questioning the prosecution's expert witnesses
In Welch's view, another of their main points is that Gutierrez did not refer to Asian macleas as an important alibi, which could have an impact on the outcome.
Rabia Chaudry, a lawyer and friend of the Syed family, when she asked Koenig that what she and Adnan's family maintained was a serious misjudgment, she was studying in law school, hosting podcasts, but not disclosing, outstanding in the case against Adnan Saeed
This further analyzes the process that led to where we are today. Or, not today-
Today, because in the HBO series, none of Saeed's advocates want him there now.
Saeed, the middle son of a Pakistani immigrant who has a close connection to the Muslim community in Baltimore, is now almost 38 years old, and he is described as a typical teenager: a football player with hot hair, A good student who smoked marijuana, had a different group of friends, was crowned Prince of the ball, and concealed his dating life from his strict parents. His close-
At his bail hearing, the knit community will be used against him, and when the prosecutor argues that he has the resources of fellow Muslims and has an uncle in Pakistan, if he fled the country, he can help him disappear.
He was remanded without bail and has not been released since then.
Anecdotes from Saeed
Like a serial that I heard but didn't see.
With regard to his friends, the dating of high school and Lee is being absorbed, and when you remember him to relay them from prison, he will be more out of harmony and he has been there for 20 years.
The new way to tell the story is to re-focus on Lee, his words --
Directly from her diary.
The cover depicts Monet's "Water Lily", which she went to the museum with her French class to buy)—Open the series.
"This book is open to those who are innocent inside.
If you feel guilty reading this, you should stop.
This book is full of my expressions.
This can make you angry, happy, angry or/and crying, so you have to take the risk yourself.
To those I love and those who love me
Love me forever, remember me forever, because I will love you forever.
"Of course, it means trouble.
Although Chaudhry has been fighting to correct legal errors, she believes that the release of an innocent person, she reiterated that the search for the truth also means justice for Haimin Lee.
"My prayers are always more than Adnan's innocence, and God will reveal the truth, because it is just for hay," she said in the series . ".
You soon realized how important the voice of the sea was from the case against Adnan Saeed --
This can't help but get lost in the details of the murder investigation --
For the proceedings, the film enhances archival photos, news clips, and trial footage in the most touching way
Inspired by the romantic, optimistic and strong mood swings found in Li's diary, the animation was drawn.
Or the "memo" She named it ".
Li is also a member of a close friend.
Strict immigrant family and Syed shares in docu
She told him in their relationship that she was sexually abused in South Korea when she was a child and that the perpetrators had never faced consequences.
A friend of Lee confirmed that she had also told her about the abuse, but she did not wish to publish such private information at the trial.
She, like Saeed, kept her love life as private as possible, and Saeed's family did not believe Adnan was dating because he had achieved such a good result.
But for all of Haihai's initial interest in Adnan, as we know from the serial, there is no uncertain term in her magazine, Lee and 22-year-
Old don kningdminster, a colleague
Her part of the worker
When she died, she was working on time at Clarence kalafters. (
In a mysterious moment in the play, Tang told the filmmaker in an interview with him in North Carolina on 2017 that he had been disabled since he was 23 years old and he didn't expect to live to be 50 years old, his main focus is to serve his wife and children. )
Adnan Syed's case took several years, but when the case ended initially his new trial application had been approved pending the outcome of the state's second appeal
There is no guarantee, but there is a lot of commitment, a certain structure.
As Serial prompted new people to present evidence in Syed's case, the culture around how to tell a major crime story has changed --
Or, if the wheels are not re-invented, elaborate wheels have become more mainstream. The Oscar-and Emmy-winning O. J.
: Manufacturing in the United States has set a golden standard for context reengineering
A review of the crime, in telling the story of The Simpsons celebrity, how it went deep into the hearts of the people, after law enforcement in Los Angeles and the relationship between the broken lottery city police and the people, no.
A guilty verdict was made against the police who beat Rodney King in the 1992 video.
At the same time, 2015 has created a very convincing case
Strategically and subjectively, according to the method of film critics,
When Steven Avery and his cousin Brendan Darcy were arrested and subsequently convicted for the 2005 murder of Teresa Halbach, the authorities were ready for him.
On 2016, Darcy's sentence was overturned, and a judge agreed that investigators forced him to plead guilty.
The decision was supported by three people.
Panel of judges from the United States
The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in the United States, but then in 11-judge panel.
Last June, United StatesS.
The Supreme Court refused to hear the case of anddseyremains in prison.
The case against Adnan Saeed explores, to some extent, the continuing criminal problems in Baltimore when Lee was killed, and the prejudices faced by the city's Muslim community (
If you think it's starting at 9/11, you're wrong, according to Chaudry)
It is effective to a large extent.
Class population of Korean immigrants.
Hae's body was 20 bodies found in Leakin Park.
Known as "City Cemetery"in five years.
While violent crime has declined in other major cities across the country, murder rates in Baltimore are rising.
Many people don't believe in the police.
When the series tracked the changing memories of the events provided by prosecution star witness Jay Wilds, Chaudry said she believed police had helped Jay "make up a story "--
First of all, he is locked due to "cell phone and cell phone record", which will prove to be a problem.
The ambiguity of what Jay told the police was amplified by the testimony of his friend Jennifer Pusateri, who saw this in the archives video and in the new interview in the series, jay spent some time in his house in the afternoon, claiming he helped Adnan bury Haimin Lee as Adnan strangled her in the Best Buy parking lot at Honda
Jenn testified that Jay told her that Adnan told him that he had killed Hae in the Best Buy parking lot;
On the show, she said, it wasn't until two weeks before Syed's murder trial began that she found out that Jay also helped bury Hae.
He first told the police that he did not help bury Hae, but admitted that he had provided assistance to adadnan with a shovel.
Earlier in the day, Adnan said that Adnan said he was frustrated that the sea had dumped him, and then he lent the car to Jay to buy a gift for Jay's girlfriend Stephanie, said he could pick him up in high school track and field practice.
Instead, Adnan (
According to multiple accounts, a friend, but not a close friend)
Called him at Jenn's and picked him up at Best Buy, and he showed him Hae's body in the trunk of her car.
Adnan and Jay then returned to their friend Cathy's house to smoke marijuana, but Adnan left after receiving a call.
The wildlife later testified at the trial that he did help Adnan dig the grave.
If that sounds complicated, it's because two weeks ago, the police conducted two interviews with Jay before getting the story that was later used directly at least to some extent at the trial.
But at the same time, in the early hours of February, shortly after the police ended their first interview with Jay.
1999, Hae's car is parked on a remote street behind a row of houses.
A few hours later, Saeed was arrested.
"I think Jay knows where the car is, just like he knows everything --
"He was told," said jodhry.
Six weeks after Adnan and Jay allegedly abandoned Hai's car in that section, Hai's car was discovered, which led Luke brendd to dig deeper into the show.
Private investigators Khym and Tyler Maroney were commissioned to review the evidence against Syed.
First of all, they talked to a long-time resident nearby who insisted that if no one called 311 or the police, there would be no unfamiliar car parked there all the time. Brindle-
Dr. Khymand Maroney also recruited a lawn scientist.
Eric Elvin from the University of Delaware helped determine whether the grass under the hay car had the characteristic of a car parked on it for a full six weeks.
Ervin's simulation results are reserved for Sunday's series finale: his sample of grass (
Grow in patch form to simulate weather conditions during that time)
As for how long the grass was exposed to these elements, he did not give a clear conclusion, but he was "very surprised" to see so many fresh things
Looking at "debris" in the tires, looking at photos of cars that have allegedly been sitting for six weeks.
Of the more than 20 times Jay was arrested or escaped, private investigator salsopuzzle-
Since 1998, together with the police, since the illegal acts from attacking police officers to having a shotgun loaded with bullets to domestic violence, they have never been prosecuted to the maximum extent of the law. An ex-
Jay's girlfriend Nikisha Horton said that while her son was sitting in the back seat, he used to beat her in the car and showed photos of her injured face, after a series of publicity, he also began investigating his past in 2016.
She allegedly asked Jay, who was living in California at the time, to make his first phone call and relay after a brief chat, and he basically told her, he gave the police a story that they wanted to get out of trouble because they were caught by a ton of weeds.
"I know it might get him excited," Horton said.
According to continuous reports, Woodlawn High School classmate Asia mcclainsaid, gutierrez never contacted her, she died on 2004, she said in a reply letter, she remembers seeing it in the library this afternoon when the prosecutor said she was killed.
She recalled in Part 3, "Justice is arbitrary," that prosecutor Kevin urrick had discouraged her from further involvement, saying they had DNA, and that a witness had said he had helped Adnan
McLean said that it was not until she listened to the serial, that she found out that they had never tested any DNA they had collected from the crime scene, nor had she found out where Hai's body was.
When McLean saw Urick testify at the 2012 hearing, after the first Syed application
She told him that she had written the letter and signed an affidavit under pressure from the Syed family, and she felt terrible.
"It's like being hit in the stomach," Chaudry said . ".
"This is a complete lie.
"After Serialaired aired, McLean reached out again and got a new affidavit in the record, and she vowed that she was not affected by any family. "[Urick]
"Convince me not to be involved," she reflected . ".
"It annoyed me.
This made me hate to allow him to manipulate me this way.
"The third part also looked at the faulty mobile tower data, which, with the help of lawyer Susan Simpson, Chaudhry helped shed light on, he wrote a paper on Jay's testimony on Serial.
Chaudry noticed, reached out and sent her all her files on Adnan's case.
They got their [cell site]
"The Map and they realize they have some very big problems because Jay's story doesn't match the phone record," Simpson said . ".
So the detectives called Jay for a second interview.
In the end, his story lined up.
"You won't turn on the recorder until you get the statement you want," Simpson said . ".
"I mean," she added, "Jay was a teenager.
A black man in Baltimore is in an interview with a murder detective who told him they wanted to sue him for murder.
The police are very good at persuading people. your best choice is to convince yourself to leave [
Your dilemma
When all you really do is talk in your wayway into it.
Said Simpson.
William Ritz, who helped challenge Jay, was involved in three other cases that led to acquittal or conviction, including Ezra Mabel, who was jailed for 10 years for murder, he was acquitted for his own legal work.
In a civil suit, he claimed that Baltimore police "deliberately gibberish and conceal evidence of innocence at all stages of the investigation" led to his wrongful conviction.
Of the men's 2013 complaints against several Baltimore officials, Ritz was listed as one of the defendants.
Lawyer C. of Saeed.
Justin Brown said on Twitter that he filed another lawsuit against the Baltimore Police Department in February, and named Liz, the chief investigator in charge of the case;
Malcolm Bryant was convicted of murder in 1998 and his conviction was revoked with the help of the Maryland acquittal program.
Simpson continues to poke holes in the phone's records, including a convenient typo, placing Jay further west, closer to the best buy he should have received a call from Adnan to find him, in Jenn's house, the correct phone code will put him there.
"I was between my house and Jenn's house at the time," Jay told police in a second interview . ".
"He asked me to meet him at best.
Jenn testified during the trial that Jay left for the first time between 3: 40 and 3: 45. m.
Jay also told police he left at about 3: 40.
"2: 36. when" come to me "called, he left for Best Buy --
But he did not leave Jenn's house until 3: 40 . "
Simpson added: "I mean, the story is meaningless.
It comes from nonsense. it is multiplied by the phone record.
They constantly introduce mistakes and they have to correct them again.
"Also, as mentioned earlier in the serial, they explained in detail (
It does help to see the fragments of the black and white affidavit)
The problem with Cell tower data.
Simpson shared the prosecutor's expert, engineer Abraham varanowitz, and I don't know that AT&T issued a disclaimer when he testified that he was using the mobile tower to locate the location, calling only outgoing calls is a reliable phone to determine the status of the location, while incoming calls
Investigators rely almost entirely on incoming calls.
"If I was told this disclaimer, it would affect my testimony," Waranowitz said in a signed affidavit . ".
Kevin Urick told us in 2015 that he was not bothered by Jay's storyline. Nor did their case matter, and he recalled where he was at agiven time in January.
1999, there is no exact match with the cell tower triangle measurement.
"I don't remember at any time we had any complaints about the evidence recorded by the phone and the story it had with Jay," Urick, who said, he left the state's law firm for private practice.
"No one is able to remember perfectly the exact time they have in a particular place, even where they are every time they call or receive a call.
Some differences are expected.
Urick said he did not respond to any requests for interviews from serial producers (
He said there was one. they said there was a lot.
Because he was a defense lawyer, he saw the real victims in the case.
"This is a young girl who was killed around the age of 18," he said . "
"When you deal with victims as a prosecutor, sometimes you have [
Their family went through a lot. .
But today, 14 years later
I do not want to be held responsible for any further pain brought to this family.
He reiterated that Asian McLean told him that when she wrote the letters, she was "under great pressure from Adnan's family ".
Jay Wilds was suspended in 2000 for five years.
Sentenced to one year in prison and two years in probation after admitting an accessory, refusing to accept a formal interview with Adnan Saeed's case, but the filmmaker finally caught up with him in January, when he spoke about the case
Initially he told the police that on the day of hayin Lee's disappearance, Adnan lent him his car so he could use it to buy his girlfriend Stephanie (
The only person who attended the sentencing hearing a year later)
Adnan is a present in high school for track and field training.
He told the filmmaker that he drove to school to return the car, but Adnan was not there.
He initially said in 1999 that Adnan first showed him the body of the sea in the parking lot of Best Buy.
The wildlife, however, told The Intercept on 2014 that Adnan showed him the body in the driveway of his grandmother's house, and he did not tell the police because he did not want to put her in trouble.
According to these words, he reiterated to the filmmaker that Adnan showed him the body in his house.
The wildlife who refused to talk to Sarah koenich told The Intercept that he thought he would eventually be mentioned in a serial.
"I think, because I'm not working with her, she will simply introduce me in the story, and then she will continue to talk about this new evidence, or anything Adnan has to tell her, he said.
"I don't think I will be demonized.
When asked by the police why he thought Adnan would call him, Jay simply replied: "I'm a criminal at Woodlawn . ".
"As he said, he told filmmaker Adnan to ask him to buy 10 pounds kilograms of marijuana, and when he did, threatened to say that if Jay didn't bury the sea for him, he will call the police.
On January, Jay also said that the idea of "seeing the body first outside Best Buy" came from the police.
"Meanwhile, Brindle-
Khymanmaroneypressed, looking to gather evidence, working for the defense at trial if they get there.
They spoke with the chief forensic doctor of Fulton County.
On January, Gorniak objected to the schedule raised by the prosecution based on the spot found on the Hae body, which insisted that she was killed at 2: 30m.
Buried around 7: 30m.
Gorniak believes that before the earliest 10: 30, the spots have not yet begun to appear. m.
This means that her body has been in a different position for a longer period of time, which is in stark contrast to the location of the hole she dug in the park.
12 samples taken from bodies and cars from the sea, including samples under nail clippers, condom wrappers and wine bottles --
Before Brown started testing last summer, the state never submitted a test --
Not matching Adnan.
The fingerprints extracted from the car rearview mirror do not match anyone in the system, and the DNA does not match.
"Nothing matches Syed," JustinBrown wrote on Twitter last Thursday . ".
"There was no forensic evidence that he was involved in the crime.
Raquel Coombs, spokesman for the attorney general's office in Maryland, retorted in a statement to The Baltimore Sun: "These results must not be exempted from his responsibility . ".
Brown wrote in an email to the newspaper: "While these DNA results do not reveal the real murderer, they do show that the wrong person is very helpful in prison. Brindle-
Khymanmaroney reiterated that police have never taken Hai's new boyfriend, Don, seriously and that she will see tang on the day of her disappearance.
There could be a loophole in his alibi, saying that he was working at Lenscrafters that afternoon, and the group pondered after contacting the then responsible laboratory manager.
Tang's mother is the branch manager of the place where he said he was.
On a day when he is not on his work schedule --
When his time card shows that he punched in and out.
Private investigators also mentioned that there may be more information about Alonzo Sellers, who reported the discovery of Hae's body when he walked into the park in February.
9, 1999, urinate.
He was previously arrested for indecent exposure. before the police turned their attention to Adnan, he was questioned after receiving an anonymous report on February.
1999. Police are advised to investigate Hae's boyfriend.
But the Maryland appeals court blocked any possible light at the end of the tunnel.
Three of the majority of the judges agreed that Adnan's lawyers were insufficient, but not enough to exceed the state's evidence against him.
Four people believe that calling Asian MacLean to the stands doesn't necessarily change anything ---
In her consent, a judge wrote that she did not believe that Asia was credible.
At the same time, two appeals courts, including those supporting Judge Welch's Decision No. 2016, discounted the key to Welch's conclusion-the improper handling of the mobile tower evidence, it was agreed that Syed gave up his right because he did not include it in his original petition of 2012, claiming that he was not adequately defended.
The special court of appeal turned its attention.
Ifs attached to McLean's "never stop"Hearing Testimony
The series includes a postscript that reveals the decision of March 8, as well as Brown's statement that they were "destroyed" but would not give up the battle.
"At the exact time of the murder, there was a credible alibi with Adnan, and now the Court of Appeal said that the witness would not affect the outcome of the proceedings, Brown told The Baltimore Sun.
"We think the opposite is true.
From the defendant's point of view, there is no stronger evidence than the non-presence witness.
"In the near future, they will" have at least three avenues of relief, "the lawyer said ".
Legal experts say they can apply to the Court of Appeal for re-consideration or try to refer the case to the United StatesS.
The Supreme Court, neither of which could examine the decision.
Adnan's family, who did not give up hope, had their own battles to fight during this period.
His mother, Shahin Rahman, was diagnosed with leukemia in 2017, and his father, Saeed Rahman, has been depressed since his son was convicted and has not left their house.
Shahming did not tell Adnan that she was ill until the end of last year and did not want to worry him.
Berg said: "It is important for the audience to see that these people are real people affected by injustice, and every person who has any relationship with this case is still in 20 years.
Adnan strangely likened the 2016 judge's ruling in favor of him to finding that he had just been "approved for chemotherapy" because he knew he had a long way to go if he was re-approved
On trial for the murder of hay
"Chemotherapy can destroy the body," he said . "
"It doesn't mean it will heal you.
Ive knows some people with terminal illness, like the only thing I can equate since I 've benefited in prison.
When someone is suffering from terminal illness for the first time, it's like talking to him, I'm going to beat him.
I'm going to beat it, you know.
And then it ends up like this, "Man, you know, I'm not going to beat it.
It will beat me. 'Talking to E!
In the news, Chaudhry said, she was most surprised during the whole process, "If the investigators --
Even defense lawyers in 1999.
They did a good job.
This is not necessarily a mystery.
You know, twenty years ago, both Lee Hai and Adnan were able to get justice.
"At the same time, Lee's family supported all efforts made by Baltimore and Maryland to keep Saeed in prison, believing that those who murdered Hae had been brought to justice.
On November, on the way to introduce to Adnan Saeed an agreement proposed by state Attorney General Brian Frosh --
Pleaded guilty and promised to be released from prison for four more years
Frustrated Justin Brown said, "they're trying to figure out what our breakthrough point is . . . . . . They did a great job of getting us to the breakthrough point.
"To answer the question of who would plead guilty to what he or she did not do, Brown said it was happening every day.
"Our criminal justice system is not always fair or correct," he said . "
"This is reality.